How Targeted Talent Recruitment Marketing Increased Qualified Applicants by 96%

OVERVIEW

Illinois faces nearly 4,000 unfilled teaching positions. Golden Apple helps fill the gap by preparing the next generation of teachers for the classroom. To expand its pool of qualified applicants in a difficult labor market, the organization needed a recruitment strategy that could consistently reach prospective educators and move them toward applying. By building a recruitment marketing operation to reach high school seniors, college students, educators and career changers, we increased applications by 96% in a single year. We tailored messages to each audience and secured their interest through email, social media, digital ads and an improved Golden Apple website and application portal.

THE REPORT CARD

96% YOY increase in highly qualified applicants to their programs

700% increase in Golden Apple website traffic to program pages

55% email open rate, nearly double the education nonprofit average

15% email click-through rate, a 7% YOYincrease and 12% higher than the industry average

THE CLIENT

Alongside honoring, supporting and developing educator excellence, Golden Apple is a nonprofit that recruits, prepares and mentors the next generation of teachers. Two programs serve this mission: the Scholars program, which supports high school seniors and early college students with tuition assistance, classroom experience and mentoring, and the Accelerators program, which helps college seniors and non-educators find a path to teaching licensure without an education degree. Golden Apple teachers stay in the classroom longer, are more likely to teach at in-need schools, and contribute to a stronger education system statewide.

Golden Apple

THE PROBLEM

The teacher shortage is ballooning: nearly 400,000 positions nationwide—or 1 in 8 classrooms—are left unfilled or are filled by underqualified hires. In Illinois alone, 4,000 unfilled teaching positions leave critical school districts without enough educators every year.
Golden Apple’s proven programs are among the best resources available to combat the shortage. But those programs needed more high-quality applicants—potential applicants who were either unaware that teaching pathways existed or unconvinced about the benefits of pursuing a career in education.

Golden Apple needed a more deliberate recruitment strategy that could find qualified candidates, address their questions about cost, program benefits and pathways into teaching, and guide them through the application process.

THE STRATEGY

Golden Apple was recruiting people at very different stages of their lives. High school students, college students and working professionals each needed a relevant reason to consider teaching, while counselors, educators and school leaders needed information they could use to recommend Golden Apple’s programs.

Our strategy was to make recruitment specific to both the audience and the decision in front of them. Using input from Golden Apple’s program and recruitment teams, common applicant questions, search behavior and application data, we identified what each audience needed to understand and what could prevent a qualified candidate from moving forward.

We used those insights to create a recruitment framework that connected Golden Apple’s value to each audience’s circumstances and supported candidates from initial interest through application. Every communication had a defined role: make teaching relevant, resolve a concern or move the candidate toward the next decision.

This gave Golden Apple a consistent recruitment structure that could reach prospective applicants directly, engage the people who influenced their decisions and respond to their needs throughout the recruitment process.

HOW WE DID IT

Reaching Each Audience with the Right Message

High school seniors, college students and career changers consider different factors when choosing a career path. We created targeted email lists that included high school seniors interested in education, college students, high school counselors, principals, superintendents and current Golden Apple participants who could share the opportunity with others.

Each audience group received information selected for its role in the recruitment process. A/B testing and message monitoring helped us to identify which subject lines, messages, and CTA’s generated the strongest response.

Answering Questions and Removing Doubts

Our review of applicant questions, search behavior and application data identified several issues preventing qualified candidates from moving forward. These included the cost of an education, uncertainty about the benefits of a teaching career and confusion about the application process.

We developed content that addressed those concerns directly, including information about financial assistance, program benefits, eligibility requirements and what candidates could expect from a Golden Apple teaching career.

Building Interest Before Application Deadlines

Prospective applicants needed to see what Golden Apple’s programs and a future teaching career could look like. We created social media graphics and short-form videos featuring Golden Apple teachers answering common questions, explaining program benefits, and sharing application tips.

We scheduled the content around recruitment milestones and application deadlines. This gave prospective applicants relevant information while they were considering the programs and deciding whether to apply.

Reaching Working Professionals

Career changers face their own recruitment questions. They need information about teacher preparation, licensure requirements, career opportunities and financial assistance for returning to school.

Through targeted LinkedIn and Google Ads campaigns, we reached people with bachelor’s degrees and early-career professionals who were considering a career change. The ads connected their interests and qualifications with a realistic path into teaching through Golden Apple.

Getting Candidates to the Finish Line

Reaching qualified candidates was only the first step. We also needed to make it easier for them to move from initial interest to an application.

We mapped follow-up emails to different stages of the consideration and application process so candidates received information that matched the questions they were likely to have at that point. We improved Golden Apple’s landing pages to clarify program benefits, eligibility requirements, application steps and what candidates should do next.

Email, website and application data showed us where candidates stopped progressing. We used that information to refine messages, pages and follow-up communications throughout the recruitment cycle.

THE OUTCOME

A 96% year-over-year increase created a much larger pool of future teachers for Golden Apple’s programs. These candidates now have an opportunity to prepare for teaching careers and serve Illinois schools that need qualified educators.

The recruitment strategy strengthened Golden Apple’s position as a trusted resource for prospective educators, removed barriers that prevented candidates from applying, and advanced its mission of inspiring, developing and supporting teacher and school leader excellence statewide.

For education nonprofits, workforce programs and other organizations recruiting in difficult labor markets, The Harbinger Group builds recruitment strategies around the full candidate journey—from identifying the right audiences and addressing their questions to delivering relevant content and improving the path to application.

Book a meeting to discuss how we can support your recruitment efforts: