Award-winning marketing campaign elevates brand during teacher shortage crisis​

In 2024, Illinois educators faced unprecedented challenges: a severe teacher shortage left thousands of positions unfilled while students grappled with pandemic-related learning loss. For over 35 years, Golden Apple has stood at the forefront of preparing, honoring, and supporting exemplary educators through their prestigious Golden Apple Awards for Excellence in Teaching & Leadership. This recognition program, known for its rigorous selection process, does more than celebrate individual excellence—it illuminates paths forward during a critical moment in education.

The Harbinger Group was engaged to transform this awards program into a catalyst for change. Our mission extended beyond recognition to address the fundamental challenges facing Illinois education. We established two core objectives:

  • First, to generate widespread awareness of Golden Apple’s mission and teacher preparation programs (Golden Apple Scholars and Accelerators) by securing more than 240 pieces of earned media coverage. This coverage would serve as a platform to showcase the programs’ impact on teacher quality and retention.
  • Second, to develop compelling content that would expand Golden Apple’s reach and achieve more than 500,000 engagements on their social media channels through organic posts and paid campaigns. These campaigns would celebrate each Award recipient within their local communities while emphasizing the critical importance of investing in teacher development.


Strategy

Our strategy centered on transforming traditional recognition moments into powerful recruitment and advocacy opportunities. Through extensive research into each nominee and finalist—including detailed reviews of applications, recommendation letters, teaching videos, and judges’ feedback—we crafted authentic narratives that resonated with both local communities and statewide audiences.

The campaign architecture followed a strategic progression designed to build momentum and maximize impact. We began with the announcement of finalists and culminated in surprise visits to award recipients’ schools. Each phase was carefully orchestrated to amplify Golden Apple’s message about the vital role of educators and showcase how their teacher preparation programs directly address the teacher shortage crisis.

Critical to our approach was the integration of local storytelling with broader advocacy. Each educator’s story became a window into both excellence in teaching and the transformative power of proper teacher preparation and support.

Execution

The campaign unfolded through a carefully synchronized combination of media relations and digital storytelling. We leveraged the compelling human-interest stories of each nominee and finalist through targeted media outreach across Illinois, focusing particularly on the communities where educators lived and worked.

Our press strategy extended beyond traditional announcements to create meaningful conversations about education. We facilitated interviews between journalists and both educators and Golden Apple spokespeople, weaving together personal achievement with systemic solutions to the teacher shortage.
In the digital sphere, we captured the emotional impact of the surprises through professional videography, creating individual stories for each recipient. These authentic moments were amplified through strategic paid promotion on Meta platforms within recipients’ local communities and shared across Facebook, X, Instagram, LinkedIn, and YouTube.

Results

We greatly exceeded our initial goal for the campaign, securing 385 earned media placements spread among all target outlet types. That represented a 114 percent increase year-over-year from 2019. Within that coverage, there were 70 links back to the Golden Apple website, helping drive additional awareness of the organization and creating opportunities for future donations and remarketing. Additionally, links to the placements were shared on social media approximately 68,100 times.

To maximize the value of the earned media placements to help increase awareness of Golden Apple, we leveraged them across a variety of marketing channels, including email and social media. This resulted in 30,700 shares of earned media placements posted by Golden Apple on social media, a 47 percent increase year-over-year in social media engagements during the Awards process, and a 20 percent increase year-over-year in new followers across social media platforms. The campaign exceeded expectations across all metrics, demonstrating both immediate impact and long-term value:

The Awards Finalists announcement generated 115 earned media stories, representing a 21% year-over-year increase, while achieving 115,000 social media engagements—15% above previous year’s performance.

The Award Recipients surprise visits campaign proved even more impactful, securing 148 earned media stories (5% year-over-year growth) and generating 535,000 social media engagements, marking a 23% increase from the previous year.

These metrics tell only part of the story. The true measure of success lies in how each piece of coverage and every social media engagement contributed to elevating the teaching profession and addressing Illinois’ critical teacher shortage. Through compelling storytelling and strategic amplification, we transformed individual recognition moments into powerful advocacy for educational excellence.